Bank of Canada worried jumbo rate cut would signal 'economic trouble,' deliberations show

Feared it could lead to expectations of further moves of the same size

Bank of Canada governing council members expressed concern that a 50-basis-point cut in October would signal “economic trouble” and worried it would lead to expectations of further moves of that size, according to a summary of deliberations released on Tuesday.

In the weeks leading up to the central bank’s decision to cut its policy rate by 50 basis points on Oct. 23, bringing the overnight rate down to 3.75 per cent, the inflation rate fell to 1.6 per cent in September, below the Bank of Canada’s two per cent inflation target. In the same month, the unemployment rate remained high at 6.5 per cent, disproportionately affecting younger job seekers.

“While members considered the merits of cutting the policy rate by 25 basis points, there was strong consensus for taking a larger step,” the summary said. “Members felt increasingly confident that the upside pressures on inflation will continue to decline, so policy did not need to be as restrictive. Further, members felt that a larger step was appropriate given the ongoing softness in the labour market and the need for stronger economic growth to absorb excess supply.”

Economic growth has slowed in the second half of this year, with gross domestic product coming in below the Bank of Canada’s expectations. The central bank’s monetary policy report in October revised its third-quarter growth forecast to 1.5 per cent, but Statistics Canada last week said growth is expected to be just one per cent.

“Overall, members noted that growth in recent months had been slightly below potential, and considerable economic slack remained,” the summary said.

Looking ahead, governing council members expect inflation to stay close to the central bank’s target and for the Canadian economy to grow by 2.1 per cent next year.

They also weighed in on a potential slowdown in population growth next year, which would impact consumption and growth, but their deliberations took place before the federal government announced it is reducing the number of newcomers coming into Canada by 21 per cent in 2025. Statistics Canada now estimates negative population growth over the next two years, below what the central bank had initially estimated.

In response to the immigration cuts, Bank of Canada governor Tiff Macklem said policymakers will look at how population growth evolves and “will be revising as we gain more confidence in what exactly is going to happen.”

Still, governing council members expressed optimism that lower interest rates would fuel stronger consumption growth, and that high interest rates and households renewing at higher mortgage rates would become factors of “less importance.” However, they acknowledged it would take time for lower interest rates to have a big enough impact on per-capita spending.

“They also recognized that given uncertainties about both population growth and how quickly lower interest rates would lead to stronger spending, the timing of the pickup in total consumption was particularly hard to predict,” the summary said.

The governing council agreed to continue to make interest rate decisions one meeting at a time based on incoming data, but members still continued to express uncertainty on what that target for neutral will be.

• Email: jgowling@postmedia.com

Bookmark our website and support our journalism: Don’t miss the business news you need to know — add financialpost.com to your bookmarks and sign up for our newsletters here.